Soaring capital flows, a debt-based consumer culture and unbalanced trade between countries all contributed to the worst financial crisis since the Great Depression. The question now is whether governments follow a 'business as usual' model based on self-interest and inequality, or one that promotes equitable development based on moral and social principles. Below is a brief overview, some key facts and further resources that relate to the global financial crisis.
Contents
Overview
Over the past 30 years the globalised economy has been predicated on unending expansion, and many argue that the resulting wealth is in fact illusory. Whilst economic expansion remains the goal of a growth-based economy, inflation - its antithesis - is paradoxically an inevitable consequence of economic growth. The battle to keep inflation low has become a major preoccupation for governments the world over.
Financial Speculation
Financial speculation on the world's stock markets has increased dramatically over this period, particularly foreign currency speculation, as have the number of financial products and funds available to speculators looking for rapid returns on their investment. The movement of capital around the world now accounts for a large percentage of economic growth, although this growth is increasingly detached from the production and consumption of goods. It remains based on the assumption that the increasing levels of debt can always be paid because the economy will always expand - and this applies equally to people, corporations and governments.
Economic destabilization
As recent history confirms, the rapid flow of capital in and out of developing countries often destabilises their economies. Since the financial crisis which began in Thailand in 1997, the inherent instability of capital flows has been globalized with disastrous consequences for other countries in S.E Asia, Latin America and Russia.
The credit crunch in the US and UK is the most recent manifestation of this international financial instability, and is a direct result of under-regulated international speculation using sophisticated debt-based financial products. The phenomenal hikes in food prices that are widely reported at present can also be attributed in part to stock-market activity, as traders buy up huge quantities of scarce agricultural produce, not primarily for consumption, but to speculate with - which increases demand and inflates the price of these essential goods.
Currently, the specter of prolonged recession haunts the US and many European countries as productive industries stagnate in the face of strong industrial advancement in the developing world. Given the primacy of the ever-weakening US dollar, mounting levels of personal and national debt, and the credit crunch, progressive analysts maintain that a full-blown international financial crisis is inevitable, and has only been temporarily delayed by swift but costly government intervention and strong economic growth in India and China.
Who Benefits?
This state of affairs suggests that the main beneficiaries of speculation in a debt-based globalized economy are financial traders and the lenders of credit, who recoup significant profits, as well as multinational corporations who thrive on this credit to expand their commercial activities and promote consumption. The bulk of humanity, on the other hand, continues to struggle with mounting levels of debt, diminishing opportunities for employment, and higher food prices.
The continued expansion of commercial activity that the endless availability of credit affords has other dire consequences for the planet which have only recently been taken seriously. These include the over-consumption of natural resources, climate change from ever-expanding production and consumption, and the cultural homogenization of society around the world.
Downsizing the Market
As financial instability plays out on the world stage, it is likely to become increasingly apparent that a stable and more equitable system of finance must be a key feature of a sustainable future economy. The role of money should be overhauled so that it works to facilitate the global exchange of goods and services without unduly rewarding those private interests which control it. A small tax on financial speculation, such as the Tobin Tax, would go a long way to reducing the damaging effects of short-term speculation whilst simultaneously creating a fund which can be used for any number of humanitarian purposes.
A further suggestion would be to limit the type and quantity of resources which are traded and speculated upon in financial markets. If essential resources such as oil and gas, and basic agricultural produce such as rice and wheat, are produced not primarily for profit but to ensure that basic needs are secured around the world, then the market speculation and price fluctuations of these essential resources would be significantly reduced, imparting a particular benefit to those in the developing world.
Key Facts
The value of the world's financial assets
In 1980 bank deposits made up 42%of all financial securities. By 2005, this had fallen to 27%, the remaining deposits were being used by capital markets and investment banks to fuel corporate development.[2]
Foreign Exchange Trading
In the year to April 06, overall turnover on the foreign exchange markets averaged around $2.9 trillion a day. That's around 60 times the value of the world's GDP for the whole year, and more than 10 times the size of the combined daily turnover on all the world's equity markets.[3]
Debt in the US
Outstanding consumer credit, including mortgage and other debt, reached $9.3 trillion in April 2003, representing an increase from $7 trillion in January 2000. The total credit card debt alone stands at $735 billion, with the household card debt of those who carry balances estimated to average $12,000.[5]
The US, being the consumer of last resort, also has the largest Gross National Debt in the world. In December 07, it stood at over $9.153 trillion, amounting to over $30,000 per person. This has been increasing on average $1.45 billion per day since September 29, 2006.[6]
The biggest chunk is held by foreign governments. Japan tops the list (with $644 billion), followed by China ($350 billion), United Kingdom ($239 billion) and oil exporting countries ($100 billion).[7]
In the US, the poorest 90 % of the population have debts equal to 75% of their financial assets, while for the richest 10 %, debts amount to only 7 % of their assets.[8]
Debt in The UK
Further resources
Organisations
- Centre for Economic and Policy Research (CEPR)
- Debtonation
- Economic Policy Institute
- Institute for Policy Studies
- New Economics Foundation
- Political Economy Research Institute (PERI)
- Re-Define: Rethinking Development, Finance & Environment
- Rethinking Finance: Alternative Voices for a New Financial Architecture
- Social Watch
- The Levy Economics Institute of Bard College
- United Nations Capital Development Fund (UNCDF)
Campaigns
- Action Aid: Campaign for Tax Justice
- Christian Aid: Nothing to Declare?
- Debtonation
- Global Witness: Banks and Corruption Campaign
- International Trade Union Confederation – Crisis Watch
- New Economics Foundation: Business, Finance and Economics
- Re-Define: Rethinking Development, Finance & Environment
- Rethinking Finance: Alternative Voices for a New Financial Architecture
- Roosevelt Institute - What Caused the Crisis?
- The Green New Deal Group
- The Put People First Coalition
- United for a Fair Economy
- War on Want: The Financial Crisis – Time for a New System
- World Development Movement: Clean the Banks!
Reports
- Crash: Why It Happened and What To Do About It?
- From Crisis Management to Institutional Reform
- I.O.U.K – Banking Failure and How to Build a Fit Financial Sector
- Macroeconomic Imbalances in the United States and Their Impact on the International Financial System
- Report of the Committee of Experts of the President of the United Nations General Assembly on Reforms of the International Monetary and Financial System
- Social Watch Report 2009: Making Finances Work - People First
- Sold Out: How Wall Street and Washington Betrayed America
- Some Reflections on the Current Global Crisis from a Developing Country Perspective
- The Brandt Equation: 21st Century Blueprint for the New Global Economy
- The Current Economic Crisis and Lessons for Economic Theory
- The Ecology of Finance
- The Financial Crisis and Its Impact on Developing Countries
- The Robin Hood Tax Report
- Too Big to Fail or Too Big to Save? - Examining the Systemic Threats of Large Financial Institutions
Articles
- Capitalism beyond the Crisis
- Debt is not Money
- How Did Economists Get It So Wrong?
- Is Islamic Finance the Answer?
- Keynes and the Crisis
- Keynes: A Man for this Season?
- Moral Bankruptcy
- The Financial Crisis and the Developing World
- The Global Financial Crisis
- The Unremarkable Record of Liberalized Trade
- Too Big to Fail versus Moral Hazard
- Wanted: Alternative Banking System
Books
- Agenda for a New Economy: From Phantom Wealth to Real Wealth
- False Profits: Recovering from the Bubble Economy
- Freefall: America, Free Markets, and the Sinking of the World Economy
- The Ascent of Money: A Financial History of the World
- The Coming First World Debt Crisis
- The Credit Crunch, Housing Bubbles, Globalisation and the Worldwide Economic Crisis
- The Ecology of Money
- The Real World Economic Outlook: The Legacy of Globalization, Debt and Deflation
- The Storm: The World Economic Crisis and What it Means
- The Trillion Dollar Meltdown: Easy Money, High Rollers, and the Great Credit Crash
- The Web of Debt
- Time for a Visible Hand: Lessons from the 2008 World Financial Crisis
Resources
- Economist's View
- Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission
- Henry C.K Liu: Independent Critical Analysis and Commentary
- This American Life: The Giant Pool of Money
- TripleCrisis: Global Perspectives on Finance, Development, and Environment
References
[1] Gerry Gold & Paul Feldman. A House of Cards, Lupus Books (2007). p.36
[i2] Ibid, p.36
[3] Ibid, p.38
[4] Ibid, p.38
[5] Joanne Laurier. US consumer debt reaches record levels (World Socialist Website, 15 January 2004)
[6] U.S. National Debt Clock (figures sourced from U.S. Department of the Treasury and the U.S. Bureau of the Census' Population Clock) accessed April 2008 <www.brillig.com/debt_clock/>
[7] John W. Schoen. Just who owns the U.S. national debt? And is growing foreign investment in the U.S. bad for America? (MSNBC, 4 March 2007). See also figures at Major Foreign Holders Of Treasury Securities (U.S. Department of the Treasury) accessed April 2008 <http://www.treas.gov/tic/mfh.txt>
[8] Ann Pettifor. Real World Economic Outlook (Palgrave Macmillan, 2003) p. 34.
[9] Gerry Gold & Paul Feldman. A House of Cards, Lupus Books (2007). p.42